跳到正文
Hacker News:AI 熱帖·· 2026-10-11AI 評分35

Nikon 一項比賽捲入生成式 AI 風波

Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions

AI 導讀

Nikon 一項比賽出現涉及生成式 AI 的違規投稿,該投稿因違反比賽規則被取消資格。留言者爭論生成式 AI 作品是否必然低質,並指出違規與作品品質是兩回事;亦有人認為攝影作品應記錄真實時空。

正文
Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions (dpreview.com)
24 points by DASD 1 hour ago | hide | past | favorite | 12 comments

Your question seems like a non-sequitur. The article is about a fraudulent entry, but you're talking about a low quality (or perhaps low-effort) entry.

Real things can be low-quality, and counterfeits can be high-quality, they are separate measures.


There is an unending stream of hate directed towards generative AI calling it "slop" with the insinuation that it must be low quality.

And yet here we have an example that is high quality. How can that be so?


Nikon is a camera company, seems perfectly reasonable to demand the videos submitted to their competition were captured by cameras and not AI generated.


Yes yes, of course. That's not my question. My question is - if the output of generative AI is slop - how is it that it keeps winning competitions?


In photography I think it’s automatically slop if it isn’t coming from an actual documentation of reality.

I don’t apply the same criteria to things that are intended as non-realistic art, you can have non-slop AI graphics, as it doesn’t matter there. But in photography there’s an expectation that the subject is a real moment in time at a real place.


Who said it was slop? All I see is it was disqualified for breaking the rules.

Why do you feel compelled to proactively defend generative AI's honor when nobody was even impugning it in this case? Kinda strange behavior IMO.


The unending stream of anti-AI comments that call all output of generative systems slop.

If you really need references I can provide them.


I don't understand how an AI can be scandalized. It's just a spicy auto complete. Sounds more like it's the photographers who are scandalized.

來源:Hacker News:AI 熱帖 · news.ycombinator.com