跳到正文
CNET· Adam Doud·· 4 天前AI 評分36

Ecovacs Goat A3000 Lidar Pro 評測:不止能割草

Our Best Robot Mower Does More Than Cut Grass

AI 導讀

Ecovacs Goat A3000 Lidar Pro 內置線式修剪器,讓機械人割草機也能修剪草坪邊緣;評測者使用逾六星期測試這項功能。它會結合 lidar 和視覺感測器辨認邊界,但修剪效果不穩,有時會漏剪或未能貼近圍欄。

正文

If there’s one major argument against robot lawnmowers — and let’s be honest, it’s not a very good argument — it’s that robot mowers can’t do everything. No matter how good a mower you have, you still have to go outside to take care of parts of your lawn that it simply cannot reach. The biggest pain point usually lies in narrow pathways in your lawn, where a robot mower, frankly, will not do a good job. But there are also the edges; most robot mowers can’t get very close to a fence or a garden wall.

The Ecovacs Goat A3000 Lidar Pro comes with a built-in string trimmer that is designed to eliminate that very problem, and it actually worked quite well for me when I tested it. That’s the good news; there’s also some bad news, which I’ll get to. But for now, I can say this mower sets a new standard for what robot lawnmowers should be able to do. I’ve been using the Ecovacs Goat A3000 Lidar Pro for more than six weeks to test this new capability. Here’s what I learned.

Starting with the basics

Before we get into the potential game changer this device could be, let’s go over some basics. The Ecovacs Goat looks very similar to last year’s Goat A3000, which I tested as part of my robot lawn mower roundup. That mower had similar dimensions, vision sensors and a lidar bulb on the top. What it did not have was a string trimmer. 

More from CNET

The cutting width is just a hair under 13 inches, which is on the larger side for robot mowers. Twin spinning discs with razor blades handle the cutting. According to Ecovacs, this device can mow up to 400 square meters per hour. My lawn, which is about 1,500 square feet, takes around half an hour to mow.

The Ecovacs’ mower navigates with a combination of GPS, lidar and vision sensors. Mapping is straightforward — you remote pilot the mower around your yard. You can then mark no-go zones and pathways for the mower to get around as it needs to. It’s very similar to how most robot mowers map a lawn.

View from the camera that sits atop the Ecovacs Goat A3000 Lidar Pro robot lawn mower.
You can see the view from the Ecovacs Goat A3000 Lidar Pro’s camera and drive the device remotely.Adam Doud/CNET

Once you have the map set up, you can schedule mows (and trims) separately. In this respect, the app is not well organized. If you want to set up a schedule, once you enter the mower’s interface, you need to swipe to the side to see the scheduling, which isn’t terribly intuitive. Neither is getting the mower into manual control mode — you need to expand a menu down to see the option. Those are two things I’d like to see fixed in future versions. You can also remotely pilot the mower around and use the camera to keep an eye on things. It’s like driving a very slow FPV RC car.

How the string trimmer works

Of course, what sets this mower apart is the string trimmer (or weed whacker or weed eater, depending on where you live). The trimmer is built into the mower’s body and has a brush you attach to it. The brush is where the trimmer emerges when it’s time to trim.

The Ecovacs Goat A3000 Lidar Pro robot lawn mower comes with a string trimmer.
The Ecovacs Goat A3000 Lidar Pro sets a new bar for robot lawn mowers by including a string trimmer that others don’t.Adam Doud/CNET

You can customize the boundary that you want trimmed, i.e., let the mower do the whole circumference of the yard, or just trim parts of the yard. This is handy if you have other plants that hang over the grass and that you don’t want trimmed, for example.

The trimmer is also very cautious around people. If you come within a meter and a half of the mower while the trimmer is active, it shuts down with a verbal warning to please stand clear. This happens whether you’re in front of, beside or behind the mower — which, by the way, made it fairly difficult to take photos of the trimmer in action. This works for humans, but not for dogs. I noticed on one occasion my little terrier mix was able to run past the mower without even a flinch from the machine. Ecovacs needs to work on that.

A round, black lidar navigation system sits on top of the Ecovacs Goat A3000 Lidar Pro robot lawn mower.
The Ecovacs Goat A3000 Lidar Pro uses lidar as its primary driver.Adam Doud/CNET

Another area Ecovacs needs to work on is the use of lidar, vision and AI when the device is in trimmer mode. This is a tale of good and bad. The good thing is that you can set the mower to use lidar to detect where boundaries actually are. I have a wooden fence with fence poles on the inside. This means every eight feet or so, a post sticks out about 4 inches back from the fence. When you’re trying to drive the mower along this fence, it’s basically impossible to map it accurately. So, Ecovacs turns to lidar and vision to detect the boundary and trim it. This is good.

What’s not so good is that it isn’t terribly effective. At times, the mower trimmed more than a foot away from the boundary; at others, it attempted to trim near my fence but left some tall grass behind. I’m not sure why, but it definitely missed some spots.

A white and black Ecovacs Goat A3000 Lidar Pro runs along a wood fence, visibly leaving some tall, uncut grass up against the fence.
The Ecovacs Goat A3000 Lidar Pro comes with a string trimmer, but it struggled to cut some of the grass right against the fence.Adam Doud/CNET

Like most other mowers, you can manually drive the mower with the remote in the app and activate the trimmer or the cutting blade (but oddly, not both at the same time) and pick up those spots you missed. This involves you standing outside and doing things, which is what the trimmer is supposed to help you avoid.

It would be fair to call the trimmer a work in progress. It’s great that it’s included, and Ecovacs is very smart to let the lidar sensor on top be the primary driver of the device, rather than a GPS boundary, which may or may not be precise. But it needs the trimmer to be much more effective before we can check that particular box. It’s definitely a case of better to have it and not need it. Overall, Ecovacs makes a strong case that every mower should have a string trimmer on it. There’s really no reason not to.

Is the Ecovacs Goat A3000 Lidar Pro worth buying?

Ecovacs Goat A3000 Pro

Goat A3000 Pro / Ecovacs Goat A3000 Pro

Ecovacs Goat A3000 Pro

  • Fast, efficient and quiet performance
  • Built-in string trimmer
  • Smart lidar implementation and effective navigation
  • Cheap plastic chassis
  • Gets stuck near tree roots

Get it now

This mower does a thorough job and has an intuitive app. The string trimmer alone can be a game changer. The mower performed well in all of my testing, including adding new areas to the map and adjusting existing ones. It also did well with obstacle avoidance in my soccer ball test, where I leave a soccer ball lying on my lawn, though it left a healthy portion of lawn around the ball unmowed — it’s conservative with obstacles. For $2,500, it’s an excellent value for what you get and earns our Editors’ Choice award.

It would be fair to say that the Ecovacs earned its place at the top of this year’s robot mower list (so far), but there is still more work to be done. Ecovacs is definitely moving in the right direction, and it should be dragging the rest of the industry along, kicking and screaming if necessary. It’s also pretty pricey, at just under $2,000 as of this writing. But I keep circling back to the key argument for a robot mower: How much is your time worth? Is saving $2,000 by buying a $500 mower and a $150 string trimmer worth spending an hour outside in 90-degree heat every week?

If you’ve convinced yourself to buy a robot mower, that’s half the battle. Once you’ve done that, this mower should absolutely be at the top of your list. It has all the right ingredients; it just needs some fine-tuning to make it a near-perfect device.

來源:CNET · cnet.com