跳到正文
Hacker News:AI 熱帖·· 7 天前AI 評分48

Jensen Huang 被指人為製造 GPU 短缺

Jensen Huang allegedly manufactured the GPU shortage

AI 導讀

Hacker News 討論帖聚焦 Jensen Huang 被指人為製造 GPU 短缺的説法,留言提及他據報資助 AI 初創企業吸納過剩晶片。有留言質疑這項指控,指出所連的 WSJ 文章並未聲稱他製造短缺,並討論 NVIDIA 在供應受限下的營收策略。

正文

Image 1Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Jensen Huang allegedly manufactured the GPU shortage (wccftech.com) 29 points by bobsoap3 hours ago | hide | past | favorite | 15 comments help Image 2bobsoap3 hours ago | next[–] Title: Instead Of Lowering GPU Prices, Former NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang Reportedly Financed AI Startups To Absorb Excess Silicon, Shattering The Shortage Perception WSJ article (paywall): https://www.wsj.com/tech/jensen-huang-colette-kress-nvidia-c... Archive link: https://archive.ph/gx14x reply Image 3Kevin_Flynn2 hours ago | parent | next[–] I read the article, and it doesn't say he did that. The article sounds to me like Jensen was attempting to maximize revenues and profits for the company he ran, like a CEO is supposed to. Is Nvidia profiting from globally constrained wafer capacity ? Absolutely. Does their strategy account for supply constraints ? Absolutely. Isn't this what corporations are supposed to do ? Adapt, pivot, profit ? I think everyones just jealous and frustrated right now, and the frustrated decided they didnt want to see leather jacket man getting laid while sipping Dom. People are petty like that, especially in large crowds. reply Image 4win311fwg51 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] As dubious as it is, if the claim of Huang manufacturing a shortage is true then revenue was not maximized. A shortage occurs when demand exceeds supply. In a normally functioning market price rises to see demand back away until demand meets supply. In order for demand to continue to exceed supply, a shortage, you must have a situation where price is prevented from rising, which, if Huang was behind it, means that Huang was purposefully rejecting better offers to keep the price below the market value. Thus revenue was artificially capped below what could have been. reply Image 5bamboozled46 minutes ago | root | parent | prev | next[–] One thing that I find quite amazing about this whole event is the way in which cheating is now much much more acceptable than in the past...not saying it's a good or a bad thing, but it's pretty wild how many people are like, "The guy was just doing what rich guys do..." reply Image 6Kevin_Flynn18 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] I view his infidelity as a broken contract between him and his wife. And thats not any of my business. Maybe she's a harpie whos terrible in bed. Maybe its his ego. Maybe he works and pays them no attention. The possibilities there are endless and unknowable. If he violated an Nvidia policy with a coworker, then the board is likely within its pervue to say something about it. They did, and the stock tanked. Fire the board. Rule by committee is powerful. You have 5 people backing each other up publicly. Especially when they are the ones who f'd up. We're the audience, and they are writing the narrative which suits them best at that moment. Go back to 2022 when this story arc started, and the US took its #1 GPU off the market in China, and trace the chess moves on all sides. Jensen got scapegoated by the Machiavellians. reply Image 7uvucyslvj15 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] Personally I’m not a fan of doing business with somebody in the habit of breaking contracts. Of course I’m sure it’ll be argued that breaking contracts is Actually Good if it makes you money. reply Image 8uvucyslvj31 minutes ago | root | parent | prev | next[–] It’s because you’re surrounded by people who think they’re currently paying their dues, and want the same leeways afforded to them once they have their bag. reply Image 9cyanydeez24 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] The embaressed short term poor, or something. They definitely think if thy pull for the billionaires, they'll get the same treatment once their takes off. reply Image 10win311fwg19 minutes ago | root | parent | prev | next[–] Jensen being forced to step down refutes your position. In the past, any such personal acts carried no professional consequences. reply Image 11camillomiller24 minutes ago | root | parent | prev | next[–] What I say instead is that we all assume it was cheating, but maybe it was just a mutual deal he had with his longtime wife as many do. But that won’t fly in puritanical America, hence apologies etc… The cheating angle is indeed bigoted and normie. reply Image 12bamboozled21 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] Many people asked the same question, why apologize and say "I hurt my family etc", he should've said, "My wife and I had agreed that my extra-marital affairs were totally fine..." ? As someone who lives in Asia, there are quite different attitudes towards this kind of thing, but an emotional love affair is still really off the table even if visiting sex workers isn't, so I don't think it's jut a puritan thing? reply Image 13win311fwg8 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] One tells the people that you made a mistake and seek forgiveness, the other challenges the entire institution of marriage which is shots fired in puritanical America. Unless you actually want to get into battle over what marriage is, is it worth it? There are no doubt some HN users that would love the battle, but I suspect someone who rose up to run a trillion dollar company is not the type of person who wants to sit around debating social norms day in, day out. Why not make up the bullshit and move on with life? reply Image 14DarkNova633 minutes ago | root | parent | prev | next[–] > The article sounds to me like Jensen was attempting to maximize revenues and profits for the company he ran, like a CEO is supposed to. Oh please. Can we end this dogma already? This is an excuse to exploit workers, create cartels, enshittify products, do stock buybacks instead of R&D and people like you rationalize this as "business as usual". Might as well say "a country is supposed to extend its borders". reply Image 15hasbot43 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] From that article: > Kress publicly defended Nvidia’s role as a banker to the broader AI industry from critics who argue Nvidia’s efforts to prop up demand across the industry has left it more vulnerable to a downturn. Kress has characterized the deals as savvy investments. > “We recognize the scale of this support, and we know some will call this circular financing. We see it differently,” she said in late August. “The equity returns on our invested capital will be excellent.” So, at least publicly, the new CEO agreed with financing AI startups. There is no indication that Huang manufactured the GPU shortages as the original article suggests. reply Image 16jon1286 minutes ago | prev[–] Nvidia wants all ML/AI running on CUDA. Amazon Web Services, Google Cloud, and those two other clowns LARPing as a cloud, give away cloud credits. As a big player, you want startups on your "platform", using your tooling, speaking and coding in your vernacular, in your flavors of things and mindsets on ways of doing things. The first sample is free. Feels great the first time around. But migrating isn't trivial. Vendor lock-in. A few quarters later, the user is scraping for more. Some startups sought to be acquired to be able to continue to fund their AWS costs because they can't do their own IT. Check out the licensing on CUDA code as it pertains to silicon, it's gnarly. Stallman would double plus disapprove that one! How many ML teams do you know, sans the one legit DevOps guy, have a genuinely agile mindset (as programmers define it) to gracefully pivot to non-Nvidia silicon? "Once a customer, always a customer", loosely something like that. Did Nvidia manipulate its own market, going far beyond the vendor imperative to give out free samples of something designed holistically for vendor lock-in? Maybe it did. But on the surface, Nvidia is acting out the nature of a vendor. As more details come out, we'll learn how much of existing insidious (though not illegal) behavior and how much of alleged behavior was at play. reply Image 17 Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact Search:

來源:Hacker News:AI 熱帖 · news.ycombinator.com