跳到正文
DEV Community· El Tayeb·· 6 小時前AI 評分46

Footnote 事實查核擴充功能為何可以回答「不明確」

Why my fact-checking extension is allowed to say "unclear"

AI 導讀

Chrome 擴充功能 Footnote 在證據不足以證實聲明時會回答「不明確」,而非強迫判定真偽;這不代表聲明為假。每項結果均附解釋和來源連結,並在可比對時顯示原文段落,也會指出頁面遺漏的背景。查核只會在用戶提出要求後開始,擴充功能不會收集瀏覽記錄。

正文

I build research tools for a living, and the last one I shipped is a Chrome extension called Footnote. You highlight a factual sentence on a web page, or check the whole page, and it tells you what the claim rests on. I am the developer, so read this as a maker's notes, not a neutral review.

The hardest product decision was not the model or the UI. It was deciding what the tool is allowed to say when it does not know.

The temptation: always give a verdict

A fact-checker that answers "true" or "false" every time feels great in a demo. It is also the fastest way to build a confident misinformation machine. If the evidence retrieved cannot establish a claim, forcing a binary answer just moves the fake news one layer down, with a nicer badge on it.

So Footnote has an "unclear" result, and it means exactly one thing: the evidence could not establish the claim. It does not mean the claim is false.

Four rules I ended up with

1. A verdict never travels alone. Every result comes with an explanation and links to the sources. The verdict is the least important part of the screen.

2. Show the passage, not just the link. A link to a 40-page report is not evidence a reader can use. Where a quotation can be matched against the retrieved source text, Footnote shows the passage behind the result.

3. Missing context is a first-class result. A lot of misleading content is accurate and incomplete: a real number without its denominator, a real quote cut in half. So the tool also surfaces context the page left out.

4. Nothing runs until the user asks. Checks start only on request, and the extension does not collect browsing history. A trust tool that watches everything you read has already lost the argument.

What it is not

It is AI-assisted, and AI can be wrong. It is a faster way to get to the sources, not a replacement for reading them. Sign-in is required, and usage limits and paid plans apply.

I would like your criticism

It is at v0.5. If you try it, I most want to hear about cases where it was confidently wrong, or where "unclear" was a cop-out.

Site and docs: https://footnote-90bdd.web.app/

How do you handle "I don't know" in your own AI features?

來源:DEV Community · dev.to