跳到正文
Hacker News:AI 熱帖·· 12 天前AI 評分25

AI 輔助獨立遊戲開發引發 Hacker News 用戶討論

Indie Game Development with AI

AI 導讀

Hacker News 用戶圍繞 AI 輔助獨立遊戲開發展開討論,焦點包括 AI 是否影響遊戲的創作價值,以及玩家會否因遊戲使用 AI 而拒玩。部分開發者認為 LLM 可讓他們把更多時間用於遊戲樂趣,也有人擔心 AI 會削弱創意和人類表達。

正文

Image 1Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Indie Game Development with AI (sandromaglione.com) 21 points by sandromaglione10 hours ago | hide | past | favorite | 12 comments help Image 2free_bip3 hours ago | next[–] If you use AI in your game I will not play it. Indie or not. I'm clearly not alone in this thinking, since the CEO of Epic Games is spreading AI-generated propaganda claiming that AI labels "hurt developers" due to significantly reduced sales. reply Image 3pjmlp34 minutes ago | parent | next[–] Certainly not Epic, given that Unreal 6 development workflow is strongly based on AI as announced recently on the Tokio Unreal 2026 event, and will even drop C++ for gameplay, it will only be supported on the core engine. reply Image 4lofaszvanitt1 hour ago | parent | prev | next[–] Everyone is using AI in the gaming industry. What you gonna do now? reply Image 5vconnor59 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] Not everyone, quit with the doomer propaganda. There is in the indie scene a large group of people and studios that refuse to adopt it, and proudly advertise this fact. In fact it might turn out to be the very thing that separates ‘indie’ from everything else. And as a player of indie games, I actively steer away from games who have been created through AI assistance, as far as it is possible to tell. reply Image 6ajjenkins2 hours ago | prev | next[–] Personally, I don’t care how a game was created (vibe coded or coded by hand) as long as the game is fun. I think it’s cool that LLMs let you focus on making the game fun rather than spending your time just getting the game to run. I’m obviously in the minority on Hacker News though. reply Image 7potsandpans1 hour ago | parent | next[–] It's nice to read. I've been developing games with ai but putting a lot of hard work into the design and development. I'm afraid to share them with a wider audience because the anti ai sentiment in the community right now is so strong. reply Image 8x______________32 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] > I'm afraid to share them with a wider audience because the anti ai sentiment in the community right now is so strong Find your audiences and cater to them, haters will always be around and will always hate as loudly as they can. Who are they to judge the creation process of another person's desires without being involved in any sort of way other than being another human with an opinion on the process used? The way we were vs who we are now. Be passionate! Offer fun games, entertain your audiences! reply Image 9khiem27942 hours ago | prev | next[–] tks for the read, I like the style of your inked game reply Image 10dolbex6 hours ago | prev | next[–] I really like the inked town game reply Image 11turpentine7 hours ago | prev | next[–] Code is creative output, and delegating it to LLMs is at the cost of that creativity. You won't know what you're missing or what lessons you would be learning. Sure, you're going "fast", and you'll ship something, but it doesn't look like meaningful engagement with the craft or an audience if a developer didn't execute on it themselves. I also read peoples posts about spending tens of thousands of dollars on local hardware that they could have hired an indie developer to work with, or throwing untold sums at online LLMs that also equate to a year or more of paid development time without LLM use. On style: the rationalization of LLM use reads like it was written by a LLM, which is kinda offputting but it also smells like highly agreeable output. reply Image 12scuttlebutt988 hours ago | prev[–] I think games like art should be one of the few areas that aren't developed by AI, because human expression is the point. I mean code, reports and other stuff, those have utility outside of the creation process itself (although the creation process still has value) but the whole point of media is human sharing. reply Image 13x______________28 minutes ago | parent[–] > I think games like art should be one of the few areas that aren't developed by AI, because human expression is the point. Being human as a perk: it lets everyone think and do as they please. People let you think as you please, let them do as they please. Why are you(or anyone) so gung-ho on restricting someone else's access to creating a game when you are not involved in their personal lives whatsoever? reply Image 14 Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact Search:

來源:Hacker News:AI 熱帖 · news.ycombinator.com