跳到正文
Semafor· Ashley Gold·· 1 天前AI 評分54

矽谷應聆聽反 AI 聲浪

Silicon Valley needs to listen to the AI backlash

AI 導讀

Ashley Gold 認為,矽谷科技領袖應更認真聆聽公眾對 AI 擴張及大型數據中心項目的反對聲音。美國中期選舉期間,全國有逾 40 項尋求限制數據中心增長的公投措施通過,支持 AI 監管的候選人亦在競爭激烈的選區勝出。文章指出,各州州長和議員正準備採取行動;特朗普本週則警告,強力 AI 監管可能「扼殺」發展。

正文

Ashley’s view

Earlier this week at Semafor’s inaugural Silicon Valley & the World conference in Palo Alto, I interviewed Senator Mark Kelly, an Arizona Democrat with some 2028 presidential buzz. At one point during our conversation, as he beamed in virtually from Washington, he described one particular data center project in New Mexico as being the size of “a thousand football fields.”

A participant in the front row rolled their eyes and shook their head, clearly exasperated at the comment. As the interview continued, the audience laughed when Kelly joked about President Donald Trump threatening to jail him, stared blankly when he spoke about regulating AI, and perked up when he talked about how Washington is thinking about investigating the controversy surrounding ousted Nvidia leader Jensen Huang.

Toward the end of the interview, Kelly made the 1,000 football field comment again, in the context of data center projects needing to be built thoughtfully — with guardrails and input from the local community. The same audience member that rolled their eyes raised their hands in disbelief. After the interview, I fact checked the claim that a data center project could be quite so large. According to a report in the investigative outlet Searchlight New Mexico, the project’s acreage is indeed equivalent to about 1,000 football fields.

The exchange was a perfect encapsulation of the dynamic between Silicon Valley and the rest of the United States right now: Those building the AI-powered future are well aware that not everyone is bought in on their vision. That was abundantly clear after the midterm elections, in which more than 40 ballot measures seeking limits on data center growth passed across the country, and candidates who embraced pro-AI regulation messaging handily won in competitive districts.

But the post-midterms soul-searching only goes so far, at least at the Rosewood Sand Hill, nestled among top venture capital firms dotting Menlo Park. From my permanent perch in Washington, I know that Silicon Valley knows they have a problem. But they’re squinting at it, red-teaming it and trying to invent their way out of it. It’s reminiscent of how Big Tech companies viewed the lawsuits, Capitol Hill investigations, and Justice Department antitrust cases that piled up as anti-tech sentiment grew in the last decade: Expensive, and a hindrance to all-out growth; but ultimately, the cost of doing business.

Tech executives are looking to keep building and growing, even as the financing gets more precarious and the infrastructure as well as the regulations that control it get harder to navigate. For many in Silicon Valley, AI anxiety and disdain can be explained away as a marketing problem, an education problem, or a location problem. For these innovators, it is not, however, a sign to stop.

This attitude from AI and tech companies is not new. But the raging anti-AI public sentiment, considerably more intense than the tech anxiety of past years, is. And governors and state lawmakers across the country are ready to pounce (some are already pouncing). So while newly empowered Democrats on Capitol Hill may not ever manage to pass significant AI regulation in the new Congress, and companies will surely find ways to appease Washington, tech leaders should perhaps take complaints about the scale of AI growth, including data center projects matching the size of 1,000 football fields — more seriously.

Room for Disagreement

Tech executives may face a hostile environment in Congress and in most of the states, but they’ve still got a powerful ally in the White House. Trump this week warned that “robust” regulation of AI could “stifle” development. “We won’t allow that to happen, frankly,” he said at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in China.

來源:Semafor · semafor.com