Apple HomeView 初步體驗:屏幕偏小,並依賴 iPhone 與 Siri
Apple HomeView First Impressions
Paul Thurrott 分享 Apple HomeView 初步體驗,指出裝置屏幕偏小,日常操作亦相當依賴 iPhone 和 Siri。桌面版和壁掛版均售 $299;裝置沒有 App Store,亦未支援 YouTube,但可透過 Audible 等支援應用程式播放內容。

Apple announced its long-delayed HomeView smart display in mid-October alongside updates to Apple TV 4K and HomePod Mini and a new collection of third-party smart home accessories called Apple Home Collection. Like many, I had been waiting for an Apple smart display for quite a long time. And so I preordered one that day and it arrived in mid-November, right on schedule, but also one week before I was back in Pennsylvania to set it up.
The most obvious and pertinent observation I have so far is that the HomeView is much too small unless the goal is to use it on your nightstand. Regardless, this is the wrong screen size for a device with only a single screen size choice. Amazon, for example, sells multiple smart display devices in various screen sizes, most of which are bigger–much bigger–than HomeView.

The shape of the HomeView screen is also controversial, and it’s perhaps one of the best examples yet of Apple’s contrarian nature. Perhaps the company was worried about it looking too much like an iPad mounted on a base, though I’d argue that the iPad’s screen shape makes more sense regardless. Plus, this shape makes it look like the world’s biggest Apple Watch, a similarity made more extreme because the apps that Apple included on the device look like Apple Watch apps too.

Despite all the leaks, the HomeView is surprising all around and this thing we got after all the delays is not at all what anyone expected.
Let us count the ways.
First, it’s not terribly expensive despite the ongoing component crisis. Whether that crisis explains the small display is unclear, but at $299 for the version with the base that can sit on a table or other flat surface–Apple also sells a wall-mountable version for the same price–is reasonable. If Apple had gone with a larger display as I’d prefer, it would have been more expensive and less of an impulse buy.
Second, Apple relies on an iPhone in the same way that Apple Watch and CarPlay do. You can set it up with an iPhone or an iPad but not a Mac, but the cross-section of users who are invested in Apple or Apple Home but don’t have an iPhone is so small it must be nearly nonexistent. And as you interact with HomeView, having an iPhone nearby and unlocked is key this being a seamless experience. The HomeView is more of a remote display than a standalone device. Which, yes, likely helped keep costs down.

Third, there’s no app store, which denies Apple and its developers with direct access to a new market tied to the company’s fastest-growing and second-biggest source of revenues. Even the Apple TV has its own app store, and is similarly a black box of sorts with relatively limited specifications compared to iPhones, iPads, and Macs.
Fourth, the HomeView user interface is clearly influenced by that of the Apple Watch, or at least its apps. The iPhone, iPad, Mac, and Apple TV all work with larger displays that have more in common with HomeView than does Apple Watch, ergonomically and otherwise. So this is a curiosity, even if you don’t think, as I do, that the Apple Watch interface is one of the company’s worst.
Fifth, the HomeView arrives without support for some very popular apps like YouTube, while many other apps, like Safari, disappear from the display when you turn away briefly so that the device can drop back into its ambient mode.

But the biggest surprise, perhaps, though this one was at least predictable, is how much HomeView expects you to interact with it using Siri AI voice control. Apple’s AI assistant got a much-needed and much-delayed set of improvements this past year, but it’s still behind Amazon Alexa and well behind Google Gemini; and isn’t it interesting that Google has yet to ship new Gemini-powered smart displays of its own? The HomeView is just the latest screen through which Siri can apologize for not understanding you or being able to do what you want.
Fortunately, my smart display needs are modest. We’ve had Android/Google Assistant-based smart displays in Pennsylvania for so many years they’re out of support, and we use a Google Pixel Tablet with its speaker dock as a smart display in Mexico. Our primary use case is photo slideshows, though I will sometimes cast a podcast, audiobook, or video to these displays from a phone when I’m doing dishes or other work in the kitchen.

Apple HomeView can handle those use cases, of course. But Apple’s lock-in presents a small problem: Though I save all my photos, regardless of which phone they were taken on, to Google Photos, only the iPhone can auto-save to Apple Photos/iCloud, and so only those photos appear on HomeView unless I remember to constantly upload any Android-based pictures to Apple’s services. Apple would prefer its users to stick with its own products and services, of course, but having that choice would be nice.
I set up the HomeView last night after we arrived back in Pennsylvania, but it was after 10 pm and I didn’t have the time or energy to get past the initial setup wizard. As with many other Apple devices, you take it out of its box–curiously large given how tiny the hardware is–and bring your iPhone (or iPad) close to it to get started. An on-screen notification sheet appears and off you go. After installing a pretty big software update, of course.
You have to choose an existing Apple Home environment (or, I imagine, create one) and a room in which the device will live, and then you can optionally configure a photo face, certain accessibility features, and which of your iPhone settings the HomeView should adopt. Then, there are a few permissions-based screens for location and personal content, and you’re finally handed off to the HomeView to finish up.
HomeView then handles activation and setting up face and voice recognition, the latter of which requires you to read five Siri AI prompts. And then you can step through a quick guide to its touch- and speech-based interfaces or just jump right in. I took a brief look around the UI and some key apps and then I went to bed. It had been a long day.
When I got up this morning, my wife, who had woken up earlier, had two comments about the HomeView: The screen is too small and the photo slideshow, which I’d not seen the night before, didn’t seem to be using particularly interesting pictures compared to the Google smart display. I agreed with her on the screen but I hadn’t really configured the slideshow per se, and I’m sure I can fix that.

The problem is that I’d have to hang out in the kitchen to do anything meaningful with the HomeView. If you go into the Apple Home app, the device appears, of course, and you can use that app to control media playback and cast content, as you do with a HomePod, but the only configurable options there are tied to Apple Home (sound recognition, intercom, listen for “Hey Siri,” and so on). The real configuration, apparently, happens on the device.

So I moved the HomeView temporarily into the living room where I can interact with it more easily. And then I spent most of today not doing that. I received several other packages I had to go through and other mail, and traveling wears me out, even when it goes well, as it did in this case.
But I have noted a few things.
The hardware is impressively premium in design. There’s a really nice metal body and though the screen doesn’t move from side to side, it can be positioned up and down.

You can swipe left and right on the HomeView face to display a different face. Among the defaults are that photo slideshow, an Apple Home dashboard, a fun date and time display with Snoopy and Woodstock from Peanuts, weather, and several others. And you can tap and hold on any face to customize it or add additional faces from a very Apple Watch-like collection.

The HomeView home screen is similar to that on iPhone and iPad, with app icons and widgets, and though you customize this screen using a similar tap and hold gesture, your options are more limited.

You remove widgets but not app icons, resize and reposition widgets, reposition app icons, and access a menu with options for adding a widget and customizing the screen, albeit just for Liquid Glass effects.

The native apps on HomeView I’ve experimented with so far seem to work pretty well and they of course look terrific. Some are apparently derived from your iPhone (or iPad), like Audible, PocketCasts, Brave, YouTube Music (but not YouTube), Instapaper (why?), and a few others, in my case, apparently using the same tech as CarPlay. But there are also orange home screen icons that represent little utilities like Intercom, Times, Alarms, and so on.

Playing content on supported apps like Audible works fine right on the device. But it’s curious you can’t arbitrarily cast any app, including content-based apps like YouTube. The HomeView doesn’t even appear in AirPlay.

That’s all I have for now. I’m not as stressed by the HomeView’s limitations as some seem to be, but the screen size and shape remain a mystery. I can only assume we’ll see a HomeView Max or whatever with a larger display in the future. For now, the initial HomeView is tiny, cute, and attractive. But I’d love a larger display.
來源:Thurrott · thurrott.com