跳到正文
Semafor· Max Tani·· 6 天前AI 評分36

新一代媒體將塑造2028年民主黨初選

A new generation of media will shape the 2028 Democratic primary

AI 導讀

左翼獨立媒體正崛起,並將影響2028年民主黨總統初選的候選人角力與議題焦點。特朗普重掌權力以來,Zeteo 的 YouTube 訂閲者增加近200萬,More Perfect Union 增加300萬。進步派媒體透過報道及訪問為左翼候選人爭取曝光,温和派陣營亦開始建立自己的媒體,以抗衡左翼網上聲勢。

正文

The Scoop

Last week, while shouting out supporters at the Muslim Public Affairs Council gala in Washington, DC, Michigan Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed singled out a figure in the crowd for special thanks: the founder of Zeteo, Mehdi Hasan, whose posts and videos pushed back against claims that progressives had underperformed more moderate candidates.

Three days later, Mississippi Sen.-elect Scott Colom told the anti-Trump digital outlet MeidasTouch that the network had given him a key boost at a moment when few people believed Mississippi would be in play for a Democratic candidate.

“Thank you for giving me the opportunity very early on, when nobody thought Mississippi would be on the radar, to tell my story, tell my message,” Colom said.

The first two years of President Donald Trump’s return to power were a waking nightmare for the Democratic Party. But in Trump’s shadow, oppositional media on the left has seen a period of extraordinary growth. Creators like Aaron Parnas, Keith Edwards, and Jack Cocchiarella gained millions of followers railing against Trump on YouTube. Independent media companies like The Bulwark, Crooked Media, and Zeteo gained millions of combined subscriptions on Substack, which grew from a platform largely favored by right-leaning or “heterodox” publishers to one dominated by left-leaning new media outlets and voices.

Scarred by Trump’s 2024 podcast tours, Democratic donors are pouring money into the independent media space, and Democratic candidates have new media figures on speed dial. And now this ascendant new media ecosystem is positioning itself to help pick the next Democratic presidential nominee — or at least weed out a few of the duds. Progressive outlets are aiming to serve as a check on traditional media that they feel wants to knock out left-wing candidates, while moderate forces are starting up their own media to try and counter a zealous left flank that has shouted down moderates online.

“That’s going to be the war more than anything: the attention fight… How can I, with the least amount of friction, get these people to start sharing clips?” Cocchiarella told Semafor.

The Left

While many legacy outlets that had experienced ratings and subscriptions growth during Trump’s first term have seen little to no meaningful gains in his second go-around, independent media outlets critical of Trump, the mainstream media, and Democratic Party leadership saw huge gains.

Since the beginning of Trump’s presidency, Zeteo has added almost 2 million YouTube subscribers. The Bernie Sanders-ite outlet More Perfect Union has added 3 million. Hasan Piker, the leftist Twitch streamer who became a midterm campaign fixation, has gained millions of followers on YouTube and increased viewership of his stream.

Now, both MPU and Zeteo are hoping to bring different issues — or candidates — to the front of the Democratic presidential primary debate.

Over the last two years, Zeteo has provided early coverage and political air cover for left-wing and socialist candidates, particularly those that have expressed aggressive criticism of Israel. In an interview on Thursday, Hasan pointed to the company’s early interviews with then-New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani and El-Sayed as examples; both were able to gain exposure to like-minded voters while other outlets were skeptical of their candidacies.

“From Zohran Mamdani’s race, to AOC’s rise, to Abdul El-Sayed’s victory, I think it’s been very clear — I’m not saying they wouldn’t have happened without us; that’s a little bit too arrogant and not accurate — but certainly they were aided and abetted and strengthened and bolstered by the fact that we exist,” he said.

Hasan said potential 2028 candidates clearly have taken notice.

Before the midterm elections, Sen. Chris Van Hollen, D-Md., said in a candid rare interview on Zeteo that he was considering running in 2028, an admission he hadn’t made on-camera anywhere else. Hasan said although his political views are clear, multiple likely candidates who do not necessarily share Zeteo’s progressive, Israel-critical stance had nonetheless been in touch in recent days about appearing on the outlet’s show.

“Democratic presidential [hopefuls] and their teams have reached out to us, not the other way around, even people we’ve criticized,” Hasan said, noting that he’s angling for an interview with Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro, a pro-Israel Democrat.

Other outlets are more interested in highlighting specific issues, but could end up tipping the conversation in favor of certain candidates that they choose to spotlight.

More Perfect Union, the viral video channel founded by Sanders advisor Faiz Shakir, has not outright endorsed candidates in races, but its story selection and tone have bolstered candidates on the left. During the midterms, the organization published a video on then-Maine Senate candidate Graham Platner titled It was less investigatory (the piece did not uncover the various scandals that later led to Platner’s decision to drop out), and more complimentary; it gave space for Platner to explain his view on various media controversies, and showed working class Platner supporters who were unbothered by the unfolding scandals.

Over the last few months, More Perfect Union has interviewed Sanders and Reps. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y. In an email, More Perfect Union Editor-in-Chief Josh Miller-Lewis told Semafor that although the organization had not finalized its 2028 plans yet, it was hoping to host multiple events with candidates. The organization also hopes to grow its More Perfect University program, which hosted town halls where candidates faced college student questioners. But primarily, Miller-Lewis said, it plans to create content that would “put candidates in conversation with working class audiences and force substantive policy discussions that are often lacking in election coverage,” citing videos the organization made with Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz during the 2024 election and El-Sayed during the 2026 Senate race.

“Our goal will be to create spaces where our working class audience has the opportunity to challenge candidates in substantive, solutions driven conversations, candidates can outline the big ideas they’ll prioritize if elected and show viewers how candidates engage with the voters they need to persuade to win,” Miller-Lewis wrote.

Beyond highlighting more ideologically aligned candidates, left-wing outlets also plan to highlight shortcomings of centrist and moderate candidates.

Ryan Grim, a founder of the foreign policy-centric Drop Site News, noted that the investigative outlet will be expanding its domestic coverage to focus on spotlighting how three powerful interest groups hope to influence the Democratic presidential primary.

“Crypto and AI, and to some extent AIPAC, are gonna wanna participate, which is wonderful, and we’re a big democracy, but we’re gonna make sure that the public knows who they’re supporting and why they’re supporting them,” Grim said in a phone call on Thursday.

Already, progressive outlets have clashed with the more moderate wing of the Democratic Party. In the leadup to Majority Democrats’ meeting last week in Denver, several progressive outlets including The Lever, a digital outlet, and The American Prospect complained that their journalists were temporarily denied press access to the event.

Fighting Moderates

The left wasn’t the only part of the Democratic-aligned media ecosystem that exploded in growth since Trump came back into power.

Crooked Media expanded its podcasts and newsletters, and grew its YouTube channel from 750,000 followers in January 2025 to 1.3 million now. Subscriptions have quadrupled since January of 2024, and the company has seen a 20% jump in podcast downloads since last year.

Last week, The Bulwark announced that it had signed a deal with Vox Media. While The Bulwark had at one point looked to bring on its own sales staff, it opted instead to partner with Vox in order to tap into the media company’s network of high-dollar advertisers, which could be sold ads across its newsletters, videos, and events, not just its podcasts. Insiders at both organizations noted that they seem less likely to take sides in a primary and more likely to serve as neutral spaces that could help shape elite leadership consensus within the Democratic Party.

Some of the more moderate parts of the party have sought to counter-program a more vocal, aggressive left flank.

In recent weeks, Majority Dems, which received a cash infusion in recent months from James and Kathryn Murdoch, stealth-launched 51st Media, a short form video-focused media company intended to help further moderate viewpoints and common ground. 51st Media operates with an editorial firewall that keeps content decisions independent from Majority Democrats, one person familiar with the project told Semafor.

In a statement, 51st Media founder Alli Peters told Semafor that the group wanted to push back against the coarseness of the current political discourse.

“Algorithms incentivize media to enforce opposing views through conflict rather than help people understand one another or imagine a better shared future,” she said. “We believe entertainment and storytelling can make important issues more accessible, reflect people’s real experiences, and help audiences see the world around them differently. The goal is content that earns its place in people’s feeds by being entertaining first and lets people form their own opinions about the issues shaping their lives.”

Others may not take sides, but could help shape the tone of the primary discourse.

In a phone call on Friday, MeidasTouch co-founder Ben Meiselas said that his organization likely would cover most of the candidates without “putting its thumb on the scale.” But he noted that MeidasTouch dislikes “mean-spirited” politics and said it would likely uplift candidates with a more positive message and tone.

“Candidates who align with those values will find a more [sympathetic] audience than those who contradict that,” Meiselas said.

Creator Wars

One of the first steps Democrats took after their 2024 election loss was elevating sympathetic new media creators. Democrats on Capitol Hill began holding “creator briefings,” or Democratic National Committee-organized creator clip-farming group chats, and donors poured money into left-aligned creators’ businesses.

Brian Tyler Cohen, a prominent Democratic creator, said his group, Chorus, had organized 30 creators on the ground in Mississippi to follow the election and raise awareness about Colom’s race. While Cohen said he didn’t plan to endorse candidates in the primary, he said some of the 200 creators in Chorus’ incubator program would likely end up using their platforms to back candidates.

Digital creators, accountable to no one but their own audiences, will be targeted by campaigns that hope to recruit them to get their message across.

Many likely 2028 candidates have spent the last several years building relationships with creators. California Gov. Gavin Newsom is on a texting basis with several of them, flagging content and occasionally fielding interview requests. Shapiro has what one Democratic staffer described as “really advanced creator infrastructure” in Pennsylvania that could be replicated in key early states.

While larger creators could stay on the sidelines, some may not have reservations about endorsing in races or running hits on candidates they don’t like.

In April 2024, Keith Edwards was a Democratic campaign veteran and former reality television producer with more than 2,000 subscribers on YouTube. But as he began churning out a daily stream of Trump-critical videos, he surged on YouTube; he now has over 1.6 million subscribers there.

While most of Edwards’ videos focus on Trump and his administration, his criticism of Jasmine Crockett in the Texas Senate Democratic primary became a point of fixation for Crockett and some of her online supporters, who accused him of being racist for questioning her electability. In the days after the primary, Crockett went out of her way to single out Edwards, who accused him of being a “paid liar.”

Edwards told Semafor that paid political creators would likely insert chaos and animosity into heated primary races.

“It’s going to be [that] on steroids,” Edwards told Semafor, saying that he would likely refrain from meeting candidates or endorsing in the primary in order to maintain objectivity. “They’re really f*cking good at ratf*cking … They’re gonna make the primaries a sh*tshow.”

Debate Me

Beyond shaping the narrative, many new media outlets and creators have another goal in mind: They expect to be included in debates.

The DNC has signaled that in addition to televised debates, it plans to host some online. Meiselas told Semafor that MeidasTouch will hold town halls, and although he had not heard anything from DNC debate planners, he said the digital outlet expected to be a top contender to host one of the expected new-media debates.

Hasan told Semafor that although his criticism of the Democratic Party likely made it a nonstarter, he’d pair up with Crooked Media and other digital new media to host a debate if candidates were receptive; he offered up Zeteo’s John Harwood as a potential moderator should the Democratic party find Hasan’s style too aggressive.

Max’s view

The last time there was a Democratic primary, much of the debate was driven by reporting in now-defunct text-based media and candidates’ supporters fighting it out on what was still called Twitter. The landscape is vastly different now; digital news outlets that drove conversation like BuzzFeed News, Vice News, and the Daily Beast are gone or diminished, and the online conversation has fragmented across platforms and communities. Short-form video and long-form podcasting, not pithy posts on X, are poised to play a greater role in defining the debate.

Democrats have been taking a victory lap over their midterm creator program, while those on the right are saying Republicans lost badly because they lost the podcasters who helped boost Trump in 2024. There are some truth to both points; the attitudes of prominent people online are meaningful vibe indicators and create permission for voters to adopt their views. But Trump’s popularity and the popularity of various candidates corresponded much more closely with gas prices than with podcast appearances or cringey clips circulated by Democrats.

A crowded primary is different. Primary voters are inherently more politically engaged and more likely to encounter and be persuaded by political or ideological media. Winning over creators, or having backing from partisan media figures with millions of followers, could make a difference in races where the margins are just a few thousand votes.

Room for Disagreement

The map may favor a more traditional television campaign. One Democratic strategist and presidential campaign veteran pointed out that in 2020, Joe Biden revived his campaign by overwhelmingly winning older Black voters, a constituency that remains tuned into television and other legacy media sources.

Rebecca Kutler, president of MS NOW, said in an interview on Semafor’s podcast this week that the network plans to play a major role in shaping the 2028 presidential primaries, both through its on-air programming, which she said has experienced a recent ratings uptick, and big-tent events like televised debates and town halls.

來源:Semafor · semafor.com