跳到正文
Hacker News 熱門(buzzing.cc 中文翻譯)·· 2 天前AI 評分53

GrapheneOS 指稱 Google 正遊説 OEM 不支援 GrapheneOS 或解鎖 bootloader

谷歌正敦促设备制造商抵制GrapheneOS和引导加载程序解锁

AI 導讀

GrapheneOS 稱 Google 多次接觸 OEM,查問其是否與 GrapheneOS 合作,並以 GMS 授權條款威脅合作方。GrapheneOS 亦稱,Play Integrity API 和 Play Store 應用程式保護功能,會在實際使用中阻止替代作業系統執行啟用相關功能的應用程式。該項目正尋求美國及歐盟政府機構關注,並希望有關機構就此向 Google 提問。

正文

Recent searches

No recent searches

Search options

Not available on grapheneos.social.

grapheneos.social is one of the many independent Mastodon servers you can use to participate in the fediverse.

Image 1: More about this server

GrapheneOS server for official project accounts and project members.

Administered by:

Image 2 admin@admin

Server stats:

3
active users

grapheneos.social:

Mastodon:

Back

Image 3 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS@grapheneos.social

Google is sabotaging their OEM partners by making a growing number of features and updates exclusive to Pixels. At the same time, Google is trying to convince OEM partners not to support GrapheneOS or even bootloader unlocking. They're also trying to harm GrapheneOS directly.

Nov 19, 2026, 08:40 PM··Web

272 boosts·5 quotes·314 favorites

Image 4 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS9h

There are a lot of engineers at Google who support what we're building and have directly worked with us. People there have repeatedly helped us and even explicitly added support for GrapheneOS to Google software including supporting Vanadium for Play services FIDO2 and passkeys.

1

Image 5 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS9h

FIDO2 and passkeys can also be used without Google Play. We had a workaround to make it work with Google Play and could have worked around the other stuff too but it's nice they implemented this. Google's engineers are not the problem. Their business people are the problem.

2

Image 6 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS9h

Google's business side is actively trying to wipe out alternatives. Google Mobile Services licensing has many illegal terms aimed at preventing competition. That isn't enough for them. They're very directly trying to harm GrapheneOS in multiple ways and outright wipe it out.

2

Image 7 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS9h

The current situation is serious. We're very interested in talking to @AGToddBlanche and others in a position to take rapid action against Google's escalating anti-competitive behavior. They're taking increasingly extreme actions to wipe out alternatives and action is needed.

2

Image 8 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS9h

There have been multiple lawsuits by the US DoJ against Google for antitrust violations with Android. Those have barely touched on the most egregious criminal antitrust violations which are currently rapidly escalating. We're interested in talking to @TheJusticeDept about it.

2

Image 9 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS9h

We expect Google will begin bootloader locking Pixels, continue heavily pushing the illegal Play Integrity API and trying to make forks of AOSP non-viable. Many of their actions are clear violation of US criminal law. US antitrust law even includes prison time for individuals.

3

Image 10 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS9h

Recent actions by Google have made it clear they're actively at war against alternatives. Our community can help us get in touch with government prosecutors and regulators. We have the resources, support and tools to continue regardless of Google's actions but won't do nothing.

4

Image 11 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS6h

Google has been repeatedly reaching out to OEMs to question whether they're working with us and threaten them based on GMS licensing terms found to be illegal by multiple courts. They're trying to stop us from having more than Pixels to support. It's completely outrageous.

6

Image 12 So JADEd@sojaded@mastodon.social9h

@GrapheneOS The EU already served Google a judgement because of several antritrust practices.

https://www.skadden.com/insights/publicati ons/2026/07/google-android-the-final-chapter

Image 13 www.skadden.com**Google Android, the Final Chapter: Court of Justice Clarifies the Standard for Exclusionary Abuse in Digital Markets | Insights | Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP**On 2 July 2026, the European Court of Justice delivered its judgment in the Google Android case, upholding the European Commission’s €4.1 billion fine against Google for abusing its dominance through pre-installation requirements, app bundling and anti-fragmentation agreements tied to Android devices. We examine the implications for companies competing in digital markets.

2

Image 14 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS9h

@sojaded It doesn't seem to have accomplished anything. Google continues rapidly escalating multiple forms of attacks on alternatives and is specifically directly attacking the GrapheneOS project.

1

Image 15 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS8h

@sojaded The EU itself is encouraging using the Play Integrity API for multiple EU standards for banks. EU countries are adopting the Play Integrity API as part of their own apps. The primary purpose of the Play Integrity API is to enforce Google Mobile Services licensing by banning any hardware or OS which isn't licensing it. They're directly enforcing the licensing terms for GMS through using it. This is the main current viability issue for GrapheneOS and they've made it far worse.

1

Image 16 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS8h *

@sojaded Google has more attacks on alternatives and also specifically GrapheneOS in progress beyond the Play Integrity API and related features. There's Play Store app protection which uses multiple measures resulting in blocking using alternative operating systems for apps enabling it in practice.

These features do not provide any serious security protection and deliberately permit devices with a decade of missing security patches. They exist to protect and expand Google's monopolies.

2

Image 17 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS8h

@sojaded What good does it do for the EU to keep fining Google for billions of dollars while never stopping their core anti-competitive behavior? They make agreements with them where Google has to do all sorts of inconsequential things which don't do anything substantial to enable competition while Google continues to rapidly escalate actions aimed at wiping it out. We talked to the EU Commission about Play Integrity and nothing happened. It has only gotten worse since we talked several times.

5

Image 18 Kylferr@kylferr@mastodon.social8h

@GrapheneOS@sojaded Because in doing do they can constantly get a cut without having to do much.

0

Image 19 Jezza™@jeremiah@shitposter.world8h

@GrapheneOS@sojaded not an accident - just a cash grab.

0

Image 20 Olivenolje@olivenolje@mastodon.social7h

@GrapheneOS@sojaded so how can we meaningfully take action to dismantle the push and adoption of Play Integrity? Should EU citizens start an EU parliament petition? Talk to our MEPs?

0

Image 21 undrendo@pglpm@c.im6h

@GrapheneOS@sojaded

We must not forget that EU is just a farce organized by some lobbies to promote their own interests under a pretense of "democracy". If we look at how the EU ruling system works, there's essentially no democracy there. People don't really matter.

<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democrat ic_legitimacy_of_the_European_Union>

Latest developments about ChatControl showed that the Parliament (the one citizens most directly – though still extremely indirectly – vote) was overridden by the Council (the one citizens don't elect) through one legislative trick or another.

Image 22 en.wikipedia.orgDemocratic legitimacy of the European Union - Wikipedia

0

Image 23 peppy@peppy@kolektiva.social3h

@GrapheneOS@sojaded If fines acted like direct reparations then maybe there would be more efficacy Image 24: :black_sparkling_heart: ... But now we're outside the limits of talking and social democracy.

0

Image 25 John Doe@abhiyantrik@mastodon.social6h

@GrapheneOS@sojaded i recently tried creating google account in GrapheneOs. It outright said I can't do that from this phone. I logged in to my previous account and tried downloading a particular app. Playstore said I can't install that app on this phone.

0

Image 26 Buccia@BucciaBuccia@mastodon.social8h

@sojaded@GrapheneOS The EU as a whole and member states are themselves enforcing Google’s business model (rather than security) by pushing Play Integrity and mandatory Google account to upcoming digital wallets.

1

Image 27 LostLLM@lostllm@ieji.de8h

@BucciaBuccia@sojaded@GrapheneOS There seems to be at least one attempt to create a fully degooglified wallet+payment app https://walt.is/ (forced to rename to Tutu soon). The payment part is currently WIP.

Image 28 walt.isWalt - Private tap-to-payPrivate tap-to-pay. No purchase tracking, no data harvesting, no AI. Just a predictable, respectful wallet app.

0

Image 29 Support GrapheneOS 667@SupportGrapheneOS_667@social.tchncs.de9h

@GrapheneOS

Try to get @noybeu involved. They already won several court cases against bigtech.

0

Image 30 C.H.@c_th1@digitalcourage.social9h

@GrapheneOS

You still have to hold out until February; as soon as the Democrats have something to say again, everything will get better, at least in the United States of America. :-)

2

Image 31 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS8h *

@c_th1 Both parties are overall very friendly with Google and both get lots of money from them. It's only the executive branch which is very relevant to this. Even the judicial branch is only relevant if the executive branch decides to deal with this. It's not going to be solved by congress. It needs to be solved by regulators and the justice department filing a lawsuit which they need to win. That's all executive branch. If they file a lawsuit then it matters what executive appointed judges do.

1

Image 32 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS8h

@c_th1 Now is as good as a time as any to try to get them to do something about it. We have a lot of connections and there are people in positions of power using GrapheneOS. We have serious potential to get them to do something regardless of which party is in power. We're not going to wait until 2029 to start defending ourselves this way.

1

Image 33 Damned@damnedd@privacysafe.social6h

@GrapheneOS@c_th1 Can you give us any more details on the plan?

1

Image 34 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS6h

@damnedd@c_th1 Current goal is getting any form of government attention on this in the EU or US. Simply having them ask questions to Google about it would solve a lot of our issues. We need Google to seriously consider the legal implications of a bunch of things they're doing. Their business side running wild with absolutely outrageous anti-competitive behavior.

It's abhorrent that they've been contacting OEMs asking about GrapheneOS and trying to convince them not to work with us.

0

Image 35 MΛYΛ@maya@gs.lexinova.eu8h

@c_th1@GrapheneOS if you think that you are fare more naive that i tough.

After Trump 1 they did not fix anythign simply go business as usual and all the illegal law of trump remained (aka cloud act who is a sovereinty violation).

So not nothing will change because they are all bribed by billionaire.

0

Image 36 ṫẎℭỚ◎ᾔ ṫ◎ℳ@TycoonTom@infosec.exchange5h

@GrapheneOS Thank you for calling this out publicly GOS.Image 37: 👍🏼
Big Tech treats users like nothing more than ad-targeting commodities,Image 38: 🫰🏼and now they’re using illegal, strong-arm tactics to crush one of the few real exits from their surveillanceImage 39: 🕵🏼ecosystem. We deserve genuine hardware choice and actual #privacy—not a forced monopoly.Image 40: 🤦🏼Keep fighting the good fight, the fediverse has your back.Image 41: 🙏🏼#Infosec

0

Image 42 BoloMKXXVIII@BoloMKXXVIII@mastodon.social5h

@GrapheneOS
I hope one of your customers is a corporate lawyer and decides to help you fight this BS.

0

Image 43 MarSOnEarth@MarSOnEarth@infosec.exchange5h

@GrapheneOS Is Motorola one of the OEMs Google reached out to?

0

Image 44 fairusr@fairusr@masto.nyc4h

@GrapheneOS

Q1. Do you have evidence to support your accusation towards Google? - "Google has been repeatedly reaching out to OEMs to question whether they're working with us and threaten them based on GMS"

Q2. Why don't you completely fork the "Android" source code and publish entire code on Github? By relying on AOSP you're tied to Google terms forever.

Q3. Why don't you collaborate with open device maker like https://www.fairphone.com/about-us

Image 45 Fairphone**We are Fairphone. Our journey so far.**We’re disrupting the industry by changing how our devices are built and produced. It’s only fair.

3

Image 46 Oliver D. Reithmaier@odr_k4tana@infosec.exchange4h

@fairusr@GrapheneOS If fair phone wanted to cooperate with GOS, they woulda done so already. Nothing in their way (except for maybe hardware/soc specs you need for GOS).

0

Image 47 Tuxicoman@tuxicoman@social.jesuislibre.net2h *

@fairusr@GrapheneOS

I think you underestimate effort to maintain and develop AOSP further. It's way above grapheneos, /e/os and fairhone capabilities combined.

There is a reason why all android phones arrive in the market with google apps preinstalled and not the ones of others (a lot of companies would be interested to push their llm, search, video, etc... apps as defaut)
Google deal support to hardware OEM against this favor. In practice it's mandatory and thus closes the ecosystem.

0

Image 48 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS1h

@fairusr Fairphone is a brand selling white labelled devices made by T2Mobile. They don't design or make devices. They do very little engineering themselves. Their devices have very poor security and don't come close to meeting our requirements. Fairphones are typical closed source ODM devices, not open devices as you said. They lag far behind a lot of mainstream devices on updates and security. There's a lack of evidence for the marketing as ethical and the poor updates hinder sustainability.

1

Image 49 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS1h

@fairusr We aren't interested in unnecessarily hard forking AOSP and are aware of how massive of an undertaking that would be. We would need to massively expand and hire hundreds of engineers. We could probably raise enough money to do that but we're nowhere close to capable of doing that yet as an organization. We need to build out our organization which means finding highly trustworthy people and gradually giving them responsibilities. We need to grow gradually, not suddenly to 500 people.

0

Image 50 Developer Dude@DevDude437@mastodon.social3h

@GrapheneOS indeed, that is horrible. Gotta love Google. Image 51: 🙄 Happy for the new Motorola partnership! Image 52: 🚀

0

Image 53 Burger B Burger :bkfls:@burger@social.burgeronthe.net30m

@GrapheneOS@grapheneos.social Genuine question, how has Motorola not been blocked from working with GrapheneOS? In the past Acer got in trouble for shipping non-GMS licensed Android forks in China, a market where GMS was banned anyways. (referring to http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2012/09/google-blocked-acers-rival-phone-to-prevent-android-fragmentation/)

Image 54 Ars Technica · Sep 15, 2012**Google blocked Acer's rival phone to prevent Android "fragmentation"**By Jon Brodkin

1

Image 55 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS3m

@burger They're working with us within the rules set by Google. There are multiple other companies with a GMS license selling devices with GMS but also offering alternatives to it. Google does their best to make it as painful as possible or outright stop it from happening. They're always around trying to convince OEMs to stop doing it too. It's why there isn't a lot more of it. The people working on the business side of Android are a bunch of outright criminals.

1

Image 56 Burger B Burger :bkfls:@burger@social.burgeronthe.net38s

@GrapheneOS@grapheneos.social What are the restrictions they have to deal with (if it's even possible to be publicly disclosed) when working with non-GMS-licensed AOSP forks? IIRC didn't you guys mention that some Motorola devices could ship with GOS preinstalled? (Unless the market had laws like requiring age attestation or other related invasive laws) Does that not break the rules of Motorola's agreement with Google?

0

Image 57 David W. Jones@dancingtreefrog@mastodon.social9h

@GrapheneOS Have you come up with an easy way to replace Android that's usable for non-developers?

3

Image 58 Jay@jaystephens@mastodon.social8h

@dancingtreefrog
Literally the point is that almost all the remaining reasons GrapheneOS is tough to use as an end user are directly caused by illegal monopoly behaviour outside of their control.

0

Image 59 atom65@atom@dresden.network8h

@dancingtreefrog@GrapheneOS

the browser-install is very easy (<20 mins for someone like me who is not very experienced. See one of my previous posts). The step of enabling "developer options" for OEM unlocking is just a scare tactic by google.

1

Image 60 David W. Jones@dancingtreefrog@mastodon.social7h

@atom@GrapheneOS Thanks, I'll have to try that. Just hope it doesn't leave me with a bricked phone or a phone that can't work with our service provider!

0

Image 61 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS7h

@dancingtreefrog Yes, our web installer. You need to have one of the supported devices. Pixels are currently what's supposed and Motorola devices will begin to be supported in 2027 starting with the Signature 27 which is the first one meeting our hardware requirements. More devices will be supported in the future.

0

Image 62 David Keck@davidskeck@mastodon.online5h

@GrapheneOS holy shit. that's insane. should i grab an extra 10a while they're around and toss GOS on it now as a backup? or is that over reaction?

1

Image 63 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS5h

@davidskeck That's an overreaction since we'll be able to add support for 11th generation Pixels once the delayed Android 17 QPR2 push to AOSP finally happens. We'll also have the Signature 27 supported soon and then future Motorola devices. We'd rather have people buy the Signature 27 after we have support for it than buying more Pixels. We're going to increasingly heavily promote the Signature 27 over Pixels once it's available and then future Motorola devices at lower price levels too.

3

Image 64 Penjoy@Penjoy@defcon.social5h

@GrapheneOS Yes, de-Google the market.

I was planning on holding back a year or so before buying the Signature 27 to replace my daily driver, which is still doing fine. But if buying now directly benefits GrapheneOS, I'll do it.

What's the shelf life of a sealed smartphone nowadays?

0

Image 65 SomeVeganCheeseIsOk@SomeVeganCheeseIsOk@mastodon.social5h

@GrapheneOS@davidskeck thank you for this advice. I've been making plans to move to your os - it's difficult to degoogle, it's in so much- and this helps.

0

Image 66 David Keck@davidskeck@mastodon.online4h

@GrapheneOS Excellent. Thanks for the advice. Google's bad behavior should not mean I buy more Google devices.

0

Image 67 derekheld@derekheld@infosec.exchange8h

@GrapheneOS you’re better off trying to talk to state attorneys general. DoJ was happy to let Ticketmaster be a monopoly and it was states that had to take over the trial.

0

Image 68 Brett@brett@bitflipp.social5h

@GrapheneOS

Todd Blanche was literally Trump’s personal lawyer he is not going to help you but he might prosecute you if you make yourself and your project known to him.

1

Image 69 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS31m

@brett Trump's DoJ continued Biden's policy of trying to break up Google. It wasn't successful but we've seen no reason to think they aren't still very interested in doing it. Trump has a grudge against Google and a case started now would likely be continued by a DoJ under the Democrats in 2029. They didn't choose the right way to go after Google for their anti-competitive Android system. It could succeed if they approached it as South Korea and recently the EU have.

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/03/07/technol ogy/trump-google-search-antitrust.html

Image 70: The Justice Department signaled in a filing on Friday that the Trump administration was continuing the Biden administration’s aggressive attempts to rein in technology giants. The New York Times · Mar 7, 2025DOJ Reinforces Demand to Break Up Google’s Search MonopolyBy David McCabe

0

Image 71 nihilistic_capybara@nihilistic_capybara@layer8.space1h *

@GrapheneOS sounds like monopolistic behaviour.

we do have laws against that in the eu. did you raise a complaint with the eu dma team?

or the canadian competition bureau ?

edit: nevermind i posted before reding the rest of the thread

1

Image 72 GrapheneOS@GrapheneOS1h

@nihilistic_capybara We haven't tried doing anything within Canada about it yet. It could be worth trying. It would be best if the US dealt with it. Splitting Android, Chrome and the Play Store from Google is long overdue. We used to worry that a spun off Android company may be less open source friendly than Google but they're headed down a path of being incredibly hostile to it anyway. We think they only keep Android open source because it helps them in the ongoing antitrust cases, etc.

0

Image 73 loonling@loonling@lgbtqia.space8h

@GrapheneOS It's always manglement and the business people ruining everything Image 74: 😭

0

Image 75 Linux and BSD are best Image 76: 🐧Image 77: 😈@LinuxBSD@mivatter.com9h

@GrapheneOS@grapheneos.social

Ultimately, it will come down to the most important question in American Business: "What does the money, want?"

Sadly, the money makes more money without privacy or freedom.

0

Image 78 Chris Hayes@chris@nutmeg.social9h

@GrapheneOS yeah, just had my state's digital ID provider tell me they won't support GrapheneOS (Play Integrity) because they only support "standard operating systems" Image 79: 😕

3


Mastodon is the best way to keep up with what's happening.

Follow anyone across the fediverse and see it all in chronological order. No algorithms, ads, or clickbait in sight.

Create accountLogin

Create accountLogin

Drag & drop to upload

來源:Hacker News 熱門(buzzing.cc 中文翻譯) · grapheneos.social